The Write Idea


Eat, Pray, Marry

Filed under: book review — ljcollins @ 4:31 pm
Tags: , , ,

Two weeks ago I heard Liz Gilbert, of Eat, Pray, Love fame, speak locally. Sponsored by Asheville’s wonderful Malaprop’s Bookstore, the speech was moved to a large auditorium at the University of North Carolina-Asheville to accommodate the crowd of several hundred (mostly) women. Let me just say that before reading EPL I was convinced I wouldn’t like it. I read it to understand what moved other people about her spiritual journey, not because I expected to be moved myself. I assumed I would find her spiritual exploration shallow and ungrounded.

Instead, I became a fan. The fact that I was a recently divorced woman when I read it may have had something to do with my reaction. I’d also like to think that I’m a discerning enough reader simply to appreciate her good writing. The girl can write, after all. But really, I loved that she let us in: she spoke of her neuroses and self-absorption and self-doubt and anger and fear and hope and love with an honesty that allowed me to sink and rise along with her emotions. Through her love of travel I flew with her to Italy and India and Indonesia, experiencing the different pace and sights and smells of each country.

So now she’s written another book: Committed, A Love Story. Actually published a while back, this book tour celebrates the paperback edition. Readers of EPL will remember that she finally succumbs to loving again near the end of her stay in Bali, having fallen for an older Brazilian man, also divorced, who gently courts her.

She does not, however, succumb to the temptation to marry. Quite the opposite, as we find out in this book. She and her beloved, Felipe, vow never to marry each other, having each been torn up by their experiences of divorce. They establish a two-continent relationship which is going just swimmingly until Homeland Security steps in and arrests and deports Felipe for misusing his temporary visas. Thus begins a journey for the two of them, internal and external, toward a legal marriage that will be recognized by the government and allow them to continue their relationship.

Liz, still being the lovable neurotic we met in EPL, can’t just consider this issue of marriage in isolation. She decides to plunge into months of research on the subject, its meaning across cultures and history, its meaning among her own family and friends, and its meaning among its promoters and detractors. The book, then, weaves the author’s all-consuming struggle to face her own marriage demons with the intellectual task of understanding what marriage actually is.

I found the result to be an enjoyable read, mixing fascinating cultural and historical tidbits, disturbing statistical reports and provocative philosophical questions with her own sweetly self-absorbed love story. It does not carry the emotional punch of Eat, Pray, Love (maybe because I’m not considering marriage any time soon?), but it does provide a good ride across southeast Asia and the history of marriage.  And it saves me reading books like Stephanie Coontz’s Marriage, a History, from which she liberally quotes.

So, to the talk then. Gilbert charmed us. She read a bit from the book and then opened the floor to questions and responded with that kind of off-hand, self-deprecating humor that one might use in a group of women friends. She easily laughed at her own foibles, the bizarre reality of her overwhelming success, seeing Julia Roberts play her on the big screen, and the terror of making her TED Talk. At the same time, she spoke of her work as a writer with reverence. She admitted to having chosen this work as a vocation when, as a teen, she lit a candle, promising to devote her life to the careful work of writing. Gilbert still feels writing to be a “holy calling”.

She described her routine of getting up early, around 5 am, and devoting the first part of her day to writing and research. Then, by about 1 pm, she says she isn’t good for much else but staring at a wall for the rest of the day. But while she believes in the hard work of staring at a blank page every single day, she also knows that the Muse makes a difference. “People say that the work is 99% perspiration and 1% inspiration, and while that may be true, you can’t dismiss that 1%. That would be like throwing out the pearl for the oyster shell.”

When writing about yourself, I suppose it helps to be likable. And Gilbert is immensely that.


  1. No! You will not entice me into reading her books! No! Noooooooo!!! But, I’m glad you found her talk engaging. I guess the only real difference between Elizabeth and us is that she gets up at 5 a.m. to write. I really can’t see myself ever doing that, but you never know…

    Comment by PJ — 02/18/2011 @ 9:46 am | Reply

  2. Seriously. 5 a.m. I like that she’s good for nothing but staring at walls after a few hours, though. You know, Peej, you might actually prefer her earlier books. She wrote three books on “manly men” subjects before the, as she says, “freakish” success of Eat, Pray, Love. She only wrote books about men and mostly wrote for men’s magazines before she fell apart and went all girly. Not that I see you as the type who reads macho books. heh.

    Comment by ljcollins — 02/18/2011 @ 9:57 am | Reply

  3. I enjoyed ELP for basically the same reasons you talk about here, and I was totally charmed by her talk for TED Talks. She presents in a very open way – and she seems like the kind of person I would like to sit down and have a cup of tea with or a glass of wine while chatting.

    Because ELP was an easy read, and I agree with you, Gilbert can definitely write, I’ll put this on my pile of TBR (to be read).

    Plus, marriage is such a fascinating, complex and complicated topic. So much culture or mores packed in there, that reading some historical takes on it would be interesting, I think. (Especially for someone like me, who has been married for a long ass time, and has had a complicated marriage, a mariagge that has found a renewal from what I thought would surely be the dirty ash of it’s demise).

    Thanks L!

    Comment by Eileen — 02/18/2011 @ 10:20 am | Reply

  4. […] last four books I bought were all during such events: one with Elizabeth Gilbert that I wrote about here, one with Louisa Shafia for her gorgeous cookbook, Lucid Food: Cooking for an Eco-Conscious Life […]

    Pingback by Presenting Heather Newton: A Beautiful Debut « The Write Idea — 03/02/2011 @ 8:38 pm | Reply

  5. Laura,

    I didn’t know you had this; I’ll tear myself away from fB now and again.

    Being such a nerd/research geek, I may want to go to the hard stuff (Coontz), but thanks for the good word about EPL (Don’t explode, Peej)

    Comment by johnieb — 03/03/2011 @ 1:34 pm | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

%d bloggers like this: